ChatGPT enthusiasts are criticizing GPT-5 on Reddit as Sam Altman gears up for an AMA.
GPT-5 has been released, and early feedback reveals a mix of emotions. Many ChatGPT enthusiasts have taken to platforms like Reddit to share their thoughts on OpenAI’s latest model, which was introduced on Thursday. A visit to the ChatGPT subreddit—an independent community—shows a variety of reactions, with some users expressing their disappointment in the model.
As the rollout continues, anticipation builds for a Reddit AMA with Altman and the OpenAI team at 2:00 p.m. ET today, where they’ll address questions about GPT-5. Users have been eager to engage, with numerous inquiries already collected. Some users wish for the return of GPT-4o as an alternative.
What Users Are Saying About GPT-5
Initial reactions are revealing a sentiment that GPT-5 may lack the “personality” that users appreciated in GPT-4o, with remarks about cooler, shorter responses. One user expressed, “GPT-4o had this warmth. It was witty, creative, and surprisingly personal, like talking to someone who understood you. Now, everything feels so sterile.” Another stated, “GPT-5 lacks the essence and soul that made ChatGPT stand out from other AI bots. I sincerely wish they would consider bringing back 4o as a legacy model.”
Other users voiced concerns about the removal of model selection options, leading some to contemplate canceling their subscriptions. A user shared, “I woke up this morning to discover that OpenAI removed eight models without any prior notice. No options, no legacy models.” This sentiment was echoed by others, highlighting a preference for the previous model system.
Interestingly, OpenAI aimed to streamline its offerings with GPT-5, responding to previous feedback about having too many model options. Expectations for GPT-5 were high, and as cognitive scientist Gary Marcus points out, while there has been “good progress on many fronts,” the model may not be the leap many users anticipated. Marcus highlights that despite significant investments, “GPT-5 is not the huge leap forward people long expected.”
The last major release from OpenAI was two years ago with GPT-4, and in that time, competitors such as Google Gemini and others have advanced in similar functionalities. For many, GPT-5 represented a crucial moment for OpenAI’s position in the AI landscape, heightening the stakes for user expectations.
While some may feel disappointed, it’s important to recognize that there are users who have shared positive experiences with GPT-5 as well. Over time, user feedback can be integral to refining the model, and OpenAI has historically responded to community input. As their mission statement emphasizes, “We believe the best way to successfully navigate AI deployment challenges is with a tight feedback loop of rapid learning and careful iteration.”
In a landscape where feedback can lead to growth and improvement, there remains a sense of hope for the future of GPT-5 and its ongoing development.
